Salmon Fishing in the Yemen

[wpramazon asin=”B008M36EEI” keyword=”comedy”]

Related Comedy Products

Terence Gavish

2 comments

  • Jay B. Lane 2 years ago
    108 of 117 people found the following review helpful
    4.0 out of 5 stars
    Nice Surprise, February 13, 2012
    By 
    Jay B. Lane (Seattle, WA USA) –
    (TOP 1000 REVIEWER)
      
    (REAL NAME)
      

    This review is from: Salmon Fishing in the Yemen (DVD)
    The Yemen is a river in the country of Yemen, which occupies the south-western corner of the Arabian Peninsula. As we know, that entire middle-eastern area is hot, dry, and arid. In this Lasse Halstrom-directed dramedy, an oil-billionaire sheik from Yemen owns several estates in Scotland and has developed a fondness for fly fishing. He dreams of a way to bring the sport to his homeland and at the same time encourage his fellow countrymen to upgrade their way of life with an improved water supply.

    We loved this cast (mostly) from the UK:
    * Emily Blunt (“The Devil Wears Prada”) is the first person contacted by the sheik. Her job is to research the practicality of the idea and make a recommendation. To complicate matters, her fiancé is soon reported missing in (military) action in Afghanistan.
    * Ewan McGregor (“Beginners”) is a mid-level bureaucrat with a touch of Asperger’s who loves fly fishing on weekends. When approached about the feasibility of this experiment, he makes outlandish demands, assuming that their cost will deter these foolish people. He is struck dumb when his demands are met, e.g., the engineers who designed the Three Gorges Dam in China.
    * Kristen Scott Thomas (“Nowhere Boy”) is a blunt, plain-spoken government official who can see the public relations advantages for news from the Mid-east that doesn’t include the escalating price of petroleum or body bags. She is hilarious in this (initially) preposterous plot and provides many laugh-out-loud moments. You will LOVE her e-mails!
    * Amr Waked (“The Father and the Foreigner”) is the fabulously wealthy sheik with the dream. It’s obvious that he is intelligent and has already studied the situation. When our troubled heroine denies she is anxious, he says, “I have too many wives not to know when a woman is upset!” We can see why this actor is a heartthrob in his native Egypt.
    * Tom Mison (“One Day”) is our heroine’s fiancé, loving, considerate AND handsome!

    I haven’t read Paul Torday’s novel on which this film is based, but knowing salmon are anadromous, I suspect the migration to salt water would be too hot and arduous, so I personally had reservations about feasibility. On the other hand, this film had far more comedy than we expected and was far more touching as well, so eventually it didn’t matter. I even got goosebumps when that fish turned around and started upstream. Nice surprise!

    I’ve signed up to be notified when this becomes available on DVD from Amazon.com

    Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 

    Was this review helpful to you? Yes
    No

  • Whitt Patrick Pond 2 years ago
    57 of 60 people found the following review helpful
    4.0 out of 5 stars
    A character-driven human comedy about faith, passion and fishing, April 5, 2012
    By 
    Whitt Patrick Pond (Cambridge, MA United States) –
    (REAL NAME)
      

    This review is from: Salmon Fishing in the Yemen (DVD)

    Salmon Fishing in the Yemen is a hard film to categorize. Directed by Lasse Hallström, with a screenplay by Simon Beaufoy adapted from the novel of the same name by Paul Torday, you could nominally call it a romantic comedy, but it’s actually far more than that. A character-driven human comedy about faith, passion and fishing comes closer. Add in an absolutely scene-stealing performance by Kristin Scott Thomas as the Prime Minister’s take-no-prisoners get-it-done-yesterday! press secretary and you’ve got Salmon Fishing in the Yemen.

    The film begins with Dr. Fred Jones (Ewan McGregor), the British government’s leading expert on fisheries, receiving an inquiry about the feasibility of introducing salmon fishing to the Yemen. Jones quickly dismisses the possibility, responding that it is simply impossible for salmon – a fish that thrives in cold fresh-water streams found in northern latitudes – to survive in a hot and arid environment like the Yemen. The inquiry, it turns out, came from Harriet Chetwood-Talbot (Emily Blunt), a consultant for a company that manages properties for a very wealthy client, Sheikh Muhammad (Amr Waked) from the Yemen. The Sheikh has a vision of salmon fishing, which he became familiar with due to his having an estate in Scotland, as not only a way to create much needed jobs for his people, but also as a way of bringing people together. Undeterred by Jones’ initial rejection and buoyed by the persuasive Sheikh’s belief in his vision, Harriet persists in pushing for a feasibility study, which Jones continues to dismiss. Until, that is, the project comes to the attention of the Prime Minister’s press secretary, the highly formidable and relentless Patricia Maxwell (Kristin Scott Thomas).

    A series of recent news items about bombings and other setbacks in the war in Afghanistan, already highly unpopular, has left the government desperately in need of “Anglo-Arabian news that isn’t about something exploding.” After tasking her staff with “We need a good news story from the Middle East, a big one, and we need it now. You’ve got an hour. Get on with it!” Maxwell seizes on the salmon fishing project as ideal for the government’s needs and pushes it forward, riding rough-shod over any and all objections as to the project’s chances of actually working. Which in turn sets everything in motion and brings all of the main characters face to face.

    Ewan McGregor’s Fred Jones is a man who muses “I was wondering if I was genetically programed to dull pedestrian life.” He’s comfortable in his government job where his biggest challenge is picking out pictures of fish to spice up his annual report; he’s married but it’s a passionless marriage, as becomes poignantly clear when his wife (Rachel Stirling) takes a several-months assignment in Switzerland, only bothering to tell him as she’s packing for the trip. Emily Blunt’s Harriet Chetwood-Talbot, on the other hand, is Fred’s exact opposite, passionate in her job and in her private life where she’s had a whirlwind romance with a hunk of an army officer (Tom Mison) who’s just been deployed to Afghanistan. And Amr Waked’s Sheikh rounds out the trio, a philosophical, quietly charismatic man who has a vision that he pursues all the more passionately because it is so impossible. A chemistry develops among the three as Fred finds himself – much to his surprise – responding to Harriet’s optimistic vivacity and to the Sheikh’s belief that the more impossible a thing is, the more it is worth pursuing, even when – or rather especially when – all you have to go on is faith. In addition to becoming not only engaged by but increasingly optimistic about the salmon project, Fred also finds himself coming to believe that other things are also possible as his working relationship with Harriet blossoms into something else. Between the two, Fred ends up making his own leaps of faith, with regard to the Sheikh’s fantastical project and to the prospect of finding real love with Harriet.

    But it is Kristin Scott Thomas’ over-the-top press secretary Patricia Maxwell with her take-no-prisoners approach to everything who supplies the comedy. A powerhouse on high heels, Maxwell dominates everyone else around her, up to and including the Prime Minister himself, and she has far and away the best lines in the film which she delivers with acerbic glee – “Is that the best you cocked-up, Oxford-educated, moronic buffoons can come up with?” She also has the best scenes, like ones showing her at home where she’s kicking her kids’ butts at computer games or ordering them off to school, and you realize that she treats the government ministers above and around her exactly the same way as she handles her kids. And the scenes showing the IM exchanges between her icon and that of the rather hapless Prime Minister are absolutely priceless.

    In addition to an engaging script and fine performances by the actors, the…

    Read more

    Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 

    Was this review helpful to you? Yes
    No

Add your comment

Your email address will not be published.